ADR 0020: ee/ stays proprietary, and only organisation features go there¶
- Status: Accepted (2026-11-15, by the maintainer)
- Date: 2026-11-15
- Issue: #394, part of #292
- Supersedes in part: ADR 0017 (the licence of
ee/and the rule for what goes there; the technical separation stays)
Context¶
ADR 0017 put ee/ under the Fair Core License with MIT as future licence
(FCL-1.0-MIT), so every version of a feature in ee/ would become MIT two
years after its release. It also left the line between core and ee/ to
each issue. ee/ is still empty, so nothing has been released under that
licence yet.
Decision¶
Licence of ee/¶
ee/has no future licence. Its code does not become MIT or any other open-source licence over time. It is source-available: anyone can read it, but it is not open source and the project does not call it that.- Licence: Elastic License 2.0 (ELv2), unless the review in #319 leads to another licence without a future grant. ELv2 allows use, change and redistribution, and forbids offering the software as a hosted or managed service, moving or circumventing the licence key (#307), and removing licence notices.
What goes into ee/¶
A feature may go into ee/ only if all three hold:
- It is only useful to an organisation with someone who administers it, not to a single person or a household.
- It is about running the instance for many people: central control of accounts and sign-in, compliance, organisation-wide communication, or connecting the instance to systems organisations use (directories, company wikis, company chat).
- The core works fully without it.
As of today this covers:
| Issue | Feature |
|---|---|
| #295 | Team tabs maintained by admins |
| #297 | Announcements |
| #299 | Absences and team calendar |
| #302 | Single sign-on for all accounts with group mapping |
| #303 | Audit log with export and retention |
| #304 | Admin policies (required second factor, session length, allowed modules) |
| #305 | Branding: own name, logo and colours |
| #307 | The licence key itself |
| #326 | Connected accounts per member |
| #327–#331 | Workplace search: Confluence, SharePoint/OneDrive, Notion, Slack, Teams |
| #332–#334 | Announcements to Slack/Teams channels, Slack app, Teams app |
| #346 | Live presence widget |
| #396 | Directory sync: LDAP, Active Directory and SCIM |
These stay in the MIT core:
- members, roles and groups (#294), invitation links and password reset without shell access (#296);
- data ownership and sharing with a group or with everyone (ADR 0018, #301);
- single sign-on for the owner (ADR 0013), two-factor authentication and passkeys (ADR 0009, ADR 0014);
- the link directory (#298) and the phone list (#300);
- every module that exists today.
Nothing moves backwards¶
A feature released in the core is never moved into ee/ and never put
behind the licence key. A feature in ee/ may move to the core at any time.
How the project describes itself¶
"Waylight is open source (MIT). Optional features for organisations are
available under a commercial licence." The documentation names ee/ plainly
as not open source and does not describe the whole repository as open
source.
What stays from ADR 0017¶
The core never imports ee/, ee/ is wired only in the composition root
behind the build tag ee, a build without the tag is MIT only, and
internal/archtest enforces both. Contributions outside ee/ are MIT
inbound and outbound with nothing to sign; contributions to ee/ need an
agreement with the maintainer.
Consequences¶
- The MIT core is unchanged. Features in
ee/stay under their licence without an end date. ee/LICENSE.mdholds the ELv2 text with Tristan L. Farinella as licensor;LICENSE,ee/README.md,CONTRIBUTING.md,README.mdanddocs/faq.mdname ELv2.- Whether published images are built with the
eetag is decided with the first feature inee/, as in ADR 0017.
Alternatives considered¶
- FCL-1.0-MIT or FCL-1.0-ALv2: both turn each version into open source after two years.
- Business Source License 1.1: requires a change date and a change licence.
- A custom commercial licence: a new text instead of a known one.
- A private repository for
ee/: rejected in ADR 0017.